Ford Fiesta ST
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Topic Options
Rate This Topic
#38529 - 17/03/06 10:01 AM Which Panel Filter??
DAVE T ST Offline
Fiesta Nutter

Registered: 15/01/06
Posts: 3556
Loc: Tipton nr. Dudley, W. Mids
When I get my I want to fit a panel filter and run it on Optimax. Which panel filter is the best???? I had alot of trouble with the K&N on my Focus and had to remove it, so I don't fancy one of those again!
Many thanks in advance
_________________________
2011 Focus 3-door Zetec 1.6 TDCi.
Previous <img src="/images/graemlins/stemo.gif" alt="" />s - 2006 Panther Black & 2007 Red. Gone and quite forgotten <img src="/images/graemlins/lol.gif" alt="" />

Top
#38530 - 17/03/06 06:53 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: DAVE T ST]
DanST Offline
Fiesta Fan

Registered: 29/04/05
Posts: 226
pipercross seems to be a favourite.

talking of them...... ive got mine sitting in my disused airbox if you want it for a tenner. did about 7000 miles but i cleaned it twice in that period.
_________________________

Top
#38531 - 17/03/06 07:59 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: DanST]
DAVE T ST Offline
Fiesta Nutter

Registered: 15/01/06
Posts: 3556
Loc: Tipton nr. Dudley, W. Mids
did it make much of a difference??
At £10 I may be interested
_________________________
2011 Focus 3-door Zetec 1.6 TDCi.
Previous <img src="/images/graemlins/stemo.gif" alt="" />s - 2006 Panther Black & 2007 Red. Gone and quite forgotten <img src="/images/graemlins/lol.gif" alt="" />

Top
#38532 - 18/03/06 06:46 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: DAVE T ST]
DanST Offline
Fiesta Fan

Registered: 29/04/05
Posts: 226
a little i suppose, people supposidley get 2-3 bhp from them.

offers better filtration than the paper filter anyway.
_________________________

Top
#38533 - 19/03/06 03:35 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: DanST]
Bishmeister Offline
Fiesta Nutter

Registered: 17/01/06
Posts: 1079
Loc: Sussex
Believe it or not, when changing your air filter to a performance filter you actually LOSE a bhp or 2. You need to be thinking about air coming out of engine for a filter to give u any more bhps e.g you need to upgrade your manifold and full exhaust system etc for the filter to give u more grunt.

Its called volemetric efficiency! lol.

Make sense ?
_________________________
Used to have: Fiesta 1.3LX, BMW 318iS E30, BMW 323i E36 and now a brand spanking new Fiesta ST.

Top
#38534 - 19/03/06 10:49 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: Bishmeister]
Happy Birthday crofty136 Offline
Fiesta Nutter

Registered: 16/10/05
Posts: 1478
Loc: Leeds
Think thats probably true about losing bhp in some cases, but i think a lot of ppl on here have had the rolling roaded and found gains.

To be honest i can't imagine you would even notice a 2bhp gain (or loss)

Top
#38535 - 20/03/06 10:05 AM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: Bishmeister]
Mase Offline
Fiesta Mad

Registered: 15/08/05
Posts: 384
Loc: Leeds
Quote:

Believe it or not, when changing your air filter to a performance filter you actually LOSE a bhp or 2. You need to be thinking about air coming out of engine for a filter to give u any more bhps e.g you need to upgrade your manifold and full exhaust system etc for the filter to give u more grunt.

Its called volemetric efficiency! lol.

Make sense ?




lol. technical terms hey!

I understand where you are coming from, volumetric efficiency is simply the amount of air that can be passed through the engine per minute. But the standard exhaust will be able to cope with pushing out more than the extra air a panel filter can put in. Thats why people will gain a small amount of power. But 2hp will be almost unoticable anyway.

If you uprate the intake a lot, say by putting on the cosworth inlet manifold, then you will also need to upgrade the exhaust to make the best out of your inlet and keep the volumetric efficiency high.

Top
#38536 - 20/03/06 05:36 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: Mase]
Bishmeister Offline
Fiesta Nutter

Registered: 17/01/06
Posts: 1079
Loc: Sussex
Mase you hit the nail on the head mate. spot on
_________________________
Used to have: Fiesta 1.3LX, BMW 318iS E30, BMW 323i E36 and now a brand spanking new Fiesta ST.

Top
#38537 - 20/03/06 05:55 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: Bishmeister]
DanST Offline
Fiesta Fan

Registered: 29/04/05
Posts: 226
sorry but thats complete shisen. no exhaust system is that ineffective that by increasing the density of the forumula in the "bang", the resulting by-products (emmisions) will cause a reduction in power.

not by the amounts we are refering to here anyway. stick a great big turbo on then yes, but add say even throttle bodies will not result in a reduction in power due to excessive back pressures. in will not operate as effeiciently but it will work.
_________________________

Top
#38538 - 20/03/06 06:26 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: DanST]
Bishmeister Offline
Fiesta Nutter

Registered: 17/01/06
Posts: 1079
Loc: Sussex
Alright dan, ya st looking sweet!

And if you was too add a performance filter to a completley standard engine....99% of the time you will actually lose BHP's. There alot of people who think they know alot about mechanics but trust its true....Ive seen the tests for all the top manufacture of performcae filters.
_________________________
Used to have: Fiesta 1.3LX, BMW 318iS E30, BMW 323i E36 and now a brand spanking new Fiesta ST.

Top
#38539 - 20/03/06 09:55 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: Bishmeister]
Mase Offline
Fiesta Mad

Registered: 15/08/05
Posts: 384
Loc: Leeds
Quote:

And if you was too add a performance filter to a completley standard engine....99% of the time you will actually lose BHP's.




I don't think that that would be true, I may be wrong tho.

Like I said before, the extra air intake from a performance panel filter will be so small in volume that the standard exhaust will be able to cope, certainly on most cars. I would imagine that all car manufacturers will build in an overhead into the capability of the exhuast, to take into account things like air temperature. (Due to thermal expansion, the cylinder will hold a smaller mass of air/fuel mixture if the temperature of the mixture is hot). Again like I said before, volumetric efficiency will only have an effect when the intake is vastly improved to bring in more air, certainly if you were to put a turbo on it DanST! But also to make the best out of significant increase in intake ability, such as a manifold, a modification to the exhuast would probalby be wise.

Top
#38540 - 21/03/06 12:02 AM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: Mase]
PinkRinse Offline
Fiesta Maniac

Registered: 02/01/05
Posts: 6067
Loc: Shoreham-by-Sea, W. Sussex, UK
Hmmm... well I gained 3 bhp with my Pipercross panel filter.
_________________________
24/03/05 to 27/06/12 & I loved it

Top
#38541 - 21/03/06 12:26 AM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: PinkRinse]
Mase Offline
Fiesta Mad

Registered: 15/08/05
Posts: 384
Loc: Leeds
My point exactly, gains WILL be seen from performance panel filters.

Top
#38542 - 21/03/06 07:52 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: Mase]
Bishmeister Offline
Fiesta Nutter

Registered: 17/01/06
Posts: 1079
Loc: Sussex
Logically you would think you would gain BHP's for installing performnce filter due to increase of cool air etc etc. But I can assure you that you will lose a couple of BHP's when having a performance filter added to a standard engine (Max power tested all the "top makes" last year). I think I should have pointed out earlier that Im talking about the "cone" filters!

I will try and find the test reults and post them on here for everyone to see.
_________________________
Used to have: Fiesta 1.3LX, BMW 318iS E30, BMW 323i E36 and now a brand spanking new Fiesta ST.

Top
#38543 - 21/03/06 08:14 PM Re: Which Panel Filter?? [Re: Bishmeister]
Mase Offline
Fiesta Mad

Registered: 15/08/05
Posts: 384
Loc: Leeds
Ah!

Well that "Cone" changes everything! I think we were all talking about panel filters (as the thread title suggests )

With a cone filter, yes you could lose some BHP, this is due to heat soak. This is when warm air is taken into the engine and like I said above this will reduce the mass of air/fuel mixture in the cylinder, leading to less power. Fitting the appropriate cold air feeds or placing the filter in a heat shield normally stops most of the heat soak and then you will gain some power again.


Edited by Mase (21/03/06 08:15 PM)

Top
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >

Moderator:  Duncan_P, kenny, Kev 
Search

Who's Online
0 registered (), 1694 Guests and 0 Spiders online.
Key: Admin, Global Mod, Mod
Shout Box

Featured Member
Registered: 11/06/26
Posts: 4
Today's Birthdays
No Birthdays
Newest Members
Zoe Fiesta, Chunzliu, dangyc, Calvin, degobaj55
8606 Registered Users
Top Posters (30 Days)
ChrisCumbria 12
Hartmann846 4
Chunzliu 3
Top Posters
ROB IS THE STIG 50824
ChrisCumbria 23932
Scotty 18100
Adam08 15118
Alex_H 15061
kenny 11807
YellowBadge 11640
steviehouse 11614
babyboom 11557
Micky 11552
Forum Stats
8607 Members
50 Forums
32288 Topics
561545 Posts

Max Online: 14753 @ 28/02/26 08:23 AM